Used cars continue to be a smart choice for buyers seeking value and quality, and 2025 brings a standout selection of pre-owned vehicles that blend reliability, efficiency, and performance. Whether you’re after a fuel-sipping commuter or a pulse-raising performance machine, this year’s top picks offer something for everyone. Among these, the BMW M2 stands tall as the best performance option, delivering excitement without losing everyday usability.
Top Used Cars Buys for 2025
Shoppers in 2025 are looking for more than just a good deal—they want cars that last, save on fuel, and still excite behind the wheel. Here are our favorite categories:
Best for Fuel Economy
Compact hybrids and fuel-efficient sedans continue to dominate this category. Models like the Toyota Prius and Honda Insight remain champions of low running costs and dependable performance. These cars often exceed 50 mpg, making them ideal for urban commuters and budget-conscious drivers.
Best for Practicality
If space and versatility top your list, the Subaru Outback and Toyota RAV4 Hybrid are top-tier choices. With all-wheel drive, solid reliability ratings, and flexible interiors, they suit both city errands and weekend getaways.
Best Performance Pick: BMW M2 (2023 Model)
The BMW M2, particularly the 2023 second-generation model, steals the spotlight as the ultimate performance pick on the used market. Originally debuting in 2016, the M2 quickly earned praise for its sharp handling and muscular power delivery. Over the years, BMW has fine-tuned the M2 into a more refined yet thrilling machine.
Under the hood of the 2023 version lies the potent S58 3.0-liter twin-turbo inline-six, now producing a thrilling 338 kW and 500 N.m of torque. Buyers can opt for either an engaging six-speed manual or the upgraded eight-speed dual-clutch automatic, both offering an exhilarating drive. This compact coupe rockets from 0-100 km/h in just 4.1 seconds—serious speed for a car that still feels connected to the road.
The M2 remains faithful to BMW’s hallmark 50:50 weight distribution, delivering crisp, balanced handling through corners. While more forgiving than its predecessor, the 2023 model hasn’t lost its edge—it can still break loose with a tail-happy attitude if provoked. With the exhaust valves open and the tachometer spinning to 7,200 rpm, it rewards drivers with an aggressive and addictive soundtrack.
Though its bold styling has sparked debate, there’s no questioning its credentials as a true driver’s car. Plus, with several low-mileage 2023 examples already entering the used market, it’s a top-tier performance option at a more attainable price.
Honorable Mention: Audi RS 4 Avant
For those who want speed with practicality, the Audi RS 4 Avant is a compelling runner-up. This high-powered wagon blends blistering acceleration with everyday comfort, making it a rare dual-purpose machine. It’s refined, family-friendly, and thrilling to drive—but a little negotiation at the dealership may help land a better deal.
The best used cars of 2025 prove that you don’t have to compromise to get the features you want. From wallet-friendly hybrids to high-octane thrillers like the BMW M2, there’s a pre-owned car for every need and desire. Whether you’re chasing fuel savings or lap times, this year’s market has never looked better.
Related article: Used Sports Cars vs. Brand-New Everyday Cars: Which Should You Choose?
