Rulani Mokwena‘s departure from Mamelodi Sundowns sent shockwaves through football fans. The 37-year-old coach had just achieved remarkable success, leading the Brazilians to a record-breaking DStv Premiership title. Yet, despite this achievement, his time at the helm came to an abrupt end.

The official explanation from Sundowns was one of “amicable parting ways” and a focus on meeting the club’s objectives. Although the decision was mutual, he didn’t want to leave the club. Mokwena stated in an interview that leaving wasn’t his choice and there’s a lot he can’t say due to a confidentiality clause, but things at the club weren’t ideal. However, due to some reports, here are the two main theories on why did Mokwena leave Sundowns:

Failing to Meet Champions League Goals: Sundowns might have downplayed the significance, but some reports suggest the club’s ambitions weren’t met in the Caf Champions League. Mokwena’s reign fell short of continental glory, a trophy the club desperately craves.
Friction with Management: Another theory centres on a potential clash between Mokwena and the club’s sporting director, Flemming Berg. Disagreements on transfer policy and playing styles might have created tension, ultimately leading to a parting of ways.

Mokwena himself has remained tight-lipped, bound by a confidentiality clause. He did acknowledge his hand being “forced” but couldn’t elaborate on the specific reasons.

The truth behind Mokwena’s departure from Mamelodi Sundowns might remain shrouded in a bit of mystery. However, one thing is certain: his achievements with the club, particularly the record-breaking league title, will be remembered. The reasons behind his exit, however, continue to be a topic of debate.