The standard of officiating in South African football has been a major talking point, with several controversial decisions sparking debate about the integrity of the game. While some claim that certain teams receive more favourable calls, the truth is that inconsistent refereeing affects all clubs, players, and supporters.
Questionable Decisions This Season
Kaizer Chiefs vs Stellenbosch FC
A recent Nedbank Cup quarterfinal between Kaizer Chiefs and Stellenbosch FC brought officiating into the spotlight. With the match level at 1-1 in the 90th minute, Chiefs’ George Matlou appeared to foul Stellenbosch goalkeeper Sage Stephens during a corner kick. Although the assistant referee signalled for the infringement, referee Sikhumbuzo Gasa consulted his colleague and ultimately allowed the goal to stand. This decision led to heated debate among fans and analysts.
Orlando Pirates vs Stellenbosch FC (MTN8 Final)
Stellenbosch FC was again at the centre of controversy during the MTN8 final against Orlando Pirates. A disputed refereeing decision saw play continue after what many believed was a clear foul, leading to a goal for Pirates. This incident intensified concerns about the consistency and fairness of officiating in the PSL.
Kaizer Chiefs vs Mamelodi Sundowns
Kaizer Chiefs have also been on the receiving end of dubious officiating. In a crucial encounter against Mamelodi Sundowns, Chiefs were denied a late equaliser due to a contentious offside ruling. Similar incidents throughout the season have raised serious questions about the standard of refereeing in the country’s top division.
The Case for Professional Referees
One of the key challenges facing South African football is the lack of full-time referees. Unlike in top European leagues, where officials dedicate themselves solely to their profession, many PSL referees balance officiating with other jobs. This divided focus limits their ability to train consistently and improve their decision-making skills.
By making referees full-time professionals, they could undergo more rigorous training, be held accountable for their performances, and deliver more consistent decisions. This would improve the overall quality of officiating and reduce errors that impact crucial matches.
Can VAR Solve the PSL Problem?
Calls for the introduction of VAR in the PSL have been growing, with many arguing that technology could help minimise refereeing mistakes. Sports Minister Gayton McKenzie recently confirmed that VAR will be implemented in April 2025, despite opposition from certain club officials.
McKenzie suggested that some individuals may be resisting VAR due to personal interests in maintaining the current system. “If you have corrupt referees or engage in bribery, why would you want VAR?” he questioned.
The estimated cost of implementing VAR in South Africa stands at R80 million, with an additional R70,000 required per match. While McKenzie did not specify the government’s financial contribution, he assured stakeholders that the necessary funding would be secured to ensure VAR becomes a reality.
South Africa remains behind other African nations like Morocco, Egypt, and Tunisia, where VAR is already in place. European leagues such as the Premier League, Bundesliga, and Serie A have been using the technology for years, significantly reducing refereeing errors in high-stakes matches.
Restoring Trust in South African Football
Ongoing refereeing controversies are damaging the credibility of the PSL. When players and coaches feel that matches are being decided by officiating errors rather than skill and strategy, the integrity of the league comes into question.
With VAR set to be introduced in 2025 and discussions around professionalising referees gaining traction, South African football has an opportunity to address these longstanding concerns. These reforms are essential to restoring trust in the game and ensuring that match results are determined on the pitch rather than by questionable officiating decisions.
Related article: Abongile Tom’s Controversial Calls: Is VAR the Answer for South African Football?
