At first glance, low-cost car insurance might seem like a smart way to save money each month. However, what many drivers don’t realise is that these cheaper options often come with strings attached — including limited coverage and high excess fees that can cost you far more in the long run than a slightly pricier policy.
The Hidden Costs of Cheap Insurance
Not all car insurance policies are created equal. Lower-priced plans often come with stricter terms and fewer benefits. Many budget insurers attract customers with low monthly premiums but then charge significantly high excess fees when you need to make a claim. As a result, the actual cost of using your insurance can be unexpectedly steep.
“You might think you’re saving, but when you need to claim, it could cost you thousands,” warns South African insurer King Price.
In addition to high excess fees, cheap policies usually offer only the most basic cover. Essential extras — such as roadside assistance, accident support, or hail damage protection — are often excluded. This stripped-down coverage can leave you financially exposed when unforeseen events occur.
Look Beyond the Price Tag
King Price recommends that consumers take a closer look at the overall value of a car insurance policy rather than just the monthly premium. “We all love a good bargain, but when it comes to car insurance, cheaper isn’t always better,” the insurer says.
Before deciding on a policy, it’s important to compare the benefits, excess costs, and terms of coverage. A slightly higher monthly premium could provide far better protection and peace of mind when it really matters.
Should You Claim? Think Before You Act
When faced with car damage, such as a scratch or dent, it’s tempting to call your insurer right away. But before doing so, ask yourself a key question: How much will the repair cost, and is it worth making a claim?
According to King Price, the cost of repairing even a minor scratch in South Africa can range from R1,000 to R5,000 or more, depending on factors such as the severity of the damage and the type of paint or parts involved. If the damage affects components like parking sensors or cameras, the cost can be significantly higher.
Now imagine your policy has a R3,000 excess. If your repair quote comes in at R2,000, claiming through your insurer means you’d pay more than if you handled the bill yourself. In this case, you’d be better off paying out of pocket.
Even with comprehensive insurance, it’s wise to avoid claiming for small repairs. Frequent claims can label you as a high-risk driver, which might lead to increased premiums at renewal time.
The Pitfalls of Minimal Coverage
Cheaper insurance options like third-party only, or third-party, fire and theft, are low-cost for a reason — they don’t cover damage to your own vehicle. So if you’re involved in an accident or your car gets scratched or dented, you’ll be left to foot the bill.
These types of policies might be suitable for older cars or occasional drivers, but for everyday use, they can prove inadequate and costly in the event of an incident.
Car insurance is more than just a legal requirement — it’s a financial safety net. While saving a few rands on monthly premiums might feel like a win, it’s important to consider the bigger picture. Limited coverage and high excess fees could turn your “bargain” policy into an expensive mistake when you need support the most.
In short, always weigh the cost of your excess against potential repairs. If the repair cost is lower than your excess, paying out of pocket might be the smarter move. And when choosing an insurer, look at more than just the monthly rate — comprehensive protection may save you far more over time.
Related article: How Much Should You Spend on a Car in 2025? Calculate Your Car Budget & Monthly Costs
