Orlando Pirates have long been a force in South African football, dominating the pitch with a flair and consistency that made them nearly untouchable. Yet, as with any dynasty, even the mightiest eventually face challenges.
In recent seasons, Pirates have shown glimpses of brilliance but also vulnerability, hinting that the tides in the Betway Premiership are shifting. Fans are now left wondering: could this be the year Pirates rise to finally end Mamelodi Sundowns’ eight-year stranglehold on the league? Momentum, strategy, and a hunger for glory will all play a part in this potential turning point.
A Crumbling Fortress?
Sundowns’ consistency over the past decade has been breathtaking. They’ve lifted eight consecutive league titles an unmatched run in South African football. Yet this season, the cracks might be starting to show.
The Brazilians have already suffered three losses in their opening ten matches and drawn once. Although they still sit at the top of the table with 21 points, their lead is far from comfortable. Sekhukhune United trail by just one point with a game in hand, and right behind them, Orlando Pirates loom dangerously close three points adrift with two games in hand.
Orlando Pirates’ Growing Belief
In the black-and-white half of Soweto, optimism is building. Orlando Pirates have been the closest challengers to Sundowns’ throne in recent years, finishing second for three consecutive seasons.
This campaign feels different. With a strong squad, renewed confidence, and two games in hand, the Buccaneers believe they can finally go toe-to-toe with the reigning champions.
Their blend of youth and experience, coupled with tactical discipline, gives them the best chance in years to disrupt Sundowns’ dominance. The gap is closing not just in results, but in mindset.

The Financial Factor
Of course, Sundowns’ empire isn’t built on tactics alone. Financially, they remain unmatched not only in South Africa but across the continent.
- Mamelodi Sundowns’ club value: R666.40 million
- Orlando Pirates’ club value: R444.30 million
Money often translates into depth, infrastructure, and squad quality all areas where Sundowns maintain a significant edge. Yet, football is rarely won on balance sheets. It’s decided by desire, precision, and sometimes, a touch of luck.
A New Dawn in South African Football?
For years, Sundowns’ supremacy has made the title race predictable. But this season feels different competitive, uncertain, and exciting. Pirates’ rise, Sekhukhune’s resilience, and Sundowns’ early wobbles have reignited hope among fans craving real competition.
Could this finally be the year the Buccaneers sink the ship of dominance? The signs suggest it’s possible if not inevitable.
While the traditional Soweto rivalry remains iconic, Kaizer Chiefs find themselves out of the picture in the title race once again. Their inconsistency leaves the spotlight firmly on Pirates to carry Soweto’s hopes of restoring balance in South African football.

The Winds of Change?
All dynasties fall eventually. Whether it’s through fatigue, transition, or the rise of a hungry rival, dominance never lasts forever.
For Mamelodi Sundowns, the question isn’t if but when the curtain falls. And for Orlando Pirates, this season might just be the moment to seize destiny and reclaim their place at the summit of South African football.
Related article: Bafana Heroes Struggle as Orlando Pirates Crumble in CAF Champions League


