Social Development Tries to Defend R3m New York Trip

The Department of Social Development has sparked heated debate after spending over R3 million on a recent trip to New York. The delegation attended the United Nations Commission on the Status of Women (CSW), one of the most influential global gatherings on gender rights.

Critics have labelled the Social Development R3m New York Trip a “joyride,” but the Department insists it was a strategic investment in diplomacy and policy influence. The controversy has not only raised questions about accountability but has also highlighted the balance between international representation and domestic austerity.

Breakdown of the R3 Million Expenditure

The Department presented its official report to Parliament’s Standing Committee on Appropriations. The figures, now public, show the trip cost R3,015,887.13 in total.

For more on Minister Tolashe, read our article: SASSA-Postbank Split to Impact Beneficiaries, Warns Tolashe.

• Flights: R1,090,463.18
• Insurance: R5,536
• Accommodation: R1,336,858.26
• Transfers: R423,964.40
• Subsistence and travel allowances: R159,065.29

Seven officials travelled, including newly appointed Deputy Director-General for Welfare Services, Sizakele Magangoe. Her expenses accounted for more than R1 million, drawing sharp public criticism.

Why the Costs Sparked Outrage

The choice of accommodation intensified the backlash. The delegation stayed at the luxury St Regis Hotel in Manhattan, where rooms cost between R33,000 and R105,000 per night.

According to travel industry expert Rachael Penaluna, the hotel offers butler service as standard. She noted:

“These rates reflect the upper tier of Manhattan accommodation and are typically reserved for high-level corporate delegations.”

Critics argue that this choice was excessive, especially in a country grappling with unemployment and poverty.

Department’s Defence: A Strategic Investment

Despite the criticism, the Department insists the trip delivered long-term benefits. It described the expenditure as an investment in South Africa’s leadership on gender equality.

The Department argued that multilateral forums like CSW allow South Africa to engage multiple partners at once, saving costs compared to bilateral trips.

“For perspective, engaging even five countries individually could far exceed the cost of one multilateral mission,” the report stated.

The Department also highlighted that in US dollar terms, the R3 million equates to about $150,000, which it considers reasonable in an international context.

Benefits Claimed by Social Development

Officials outlined several policy and funding benefits linked to South Africa’s participation at CSW over the years:

• In 2019, South Africa successfully advocated for recognition of unpaid care work and stronger social protection systems.
• In 2021, the country helped secure commitments to combat gender-based violence (GBV).
• The UN Women Spotlight Initiative channelled nearly €30 million into GBV programmes in South Africa.
• South Africa’s gender-responsive budgeting models drew inspiration from countries like Canada, Mexico, and Sweden.

“Our participation gave visibility to the National Strategic Plan on GBVF, attracting global recognition and technical support,” the Department said.

The Magangoe Question

Deputy DG Sizakele Magangoe’s costs have faced the harshest scrutiny. Her reported expenditure included:

• Air ticket: R178,892
• Travel insurance: R1,088
• Hotel accommodation: R388,833
• Transfers: R419,464
• Allowance: R40,196

However, the Department clarified that the local travel transfers for the delegation were consolidated under her costs, not spent solely on her.

Read more about the latest courtroom revelations in our coverage: Phala Phala Trial: Witness Explains Cash Hidden in Ramaphosa’s Couch.

Internal Fallout: Suspension of Spokesperson

The scandal widened when Lumka Oliphant, the Department’s Chief Director of Communications, was suspended with full pay.

According to reports, she was accused of leaking details of the trip to the media. However, she strongly denied this, saying:

“The charges are trumped up … The information was already in the public domain through parliamentary questions.”

Director-General Peter Netshipale defended the suspension, stating it was necessary “to investigate without hindrance.”

Comparative Spending by Other Departments

The DSD was not the only government entity at CSW. Reports show:

• The Department of Women, Youth and People with Disabilities spent R2 million on five delegates.
• The Department of Higher Education spent R1.6 million on another five.

This context suggests that the DSD’s spending, while higher, was not unique in scale.

Commitment to Transparency and Reform

Minister Sisisi Tolashe has since pledged to improve transparency and accountability. In an official statement via SAnews, she said:

“We are committed to achieving clean audits under the Medium-Term Expenditure Framework. Anything not accomplished in 2023/24 will be integrated into the 2024/25 action plans.”

The Department also announced plans to:

• Publish future UN engagement reports online.
• Track funding secured, partnerships formed, and policy influence.
• Report tangible outcomes in its annual reports.

Balancing Diplomacy and Domestic Needs

The Social Development R3m New York Trip underscores a dilemma: balancing global leadership with domestic austerity.

On one hand, South Africa’s participation has secured millions in donor funding and shaped international gender policies. On the other hand, luxury hotels and million-rand line items fuel public anger.

The Department insists that not attending would have been far more costly for women and girls in South Africa.

Lessons Moving Forward

The debate around the Social Development R3m New York Trip reflects broader questions of governance and accountability.

Key lessons include:

• Government departments must justify international trips with measurable outcomes.
• Transparent reporting can rebuild public trust.
• Cost efficiency must be a priority, even in diplomacy.

Discover the full story in our report: Tembisa Hospital Fraud Investigation Links Syndicate to Ramaphosa’s Nephew.

Ultimately, the controversy may push Social Development to tighten internal controls and demonstrate value for every rand spent abroad.