The enrollment of undocumented children in South African schools has ignited a heated debate, with strong opinions on both sides of the issue. Critics argue that this decision places an additional burden on an already strained education system, while advocates stress the importance of upholding children’s rights regardless of their legal status.
ALSO READ: 2025 School Calendar: Term Dates, New Curriculum Subjects, and Special Holidays
The Controversy Unfolds
The controversy began with a parliamentary response revealing that in 2020, over 177,677 foreign nationals—excluding those in the Eastern Cape—could not be tracked within the education system. This revelation has reignited concerns about the inclusion of undocumented children in schools and its implications for the country.
Herman Mashaba, leader of ActionSA, has been a vocal critic of the move. Mashaba described it as a “threat to sovereignty and a legitimization of illegality,” claiming it sends a dangerous message to failed states, encouraging them to offload their responsibilities onto South Africa.
“This isn’t just about schools; it signals that South Africa is open to exploitation,” Mashaba said, pointing to the country’s challenges, including 54% of the population living below the poverty line and high unemployment rates.
Strain on Resources
Mashaba’s critique highlights the significant strain on South Africa’s education system. Many public schools face overcrowding, inadequate infrastructure, and outdated facilities, such as pit toilets. The inclusion of undocumented children in schools raises questions about how the government will allocate resources to address these existing challenges while accommodating additional learners.
“Some public schools are already dysfunctional and dilapidated,” Mashaba noted. “If the government cannot uphold the dignity of South African children, how will it find resources for undocumented children?”
Legal and Human Rights Perspectives
Despite these criticisms, the enrollment of undocumented children has legal backing. A 2019 High Court ruling mandated that schools must admit undocumented learners, declaring clauses in the School Admission Policy unconstitutional.
Dr. Vusumuzi Sibanda, representing the African Diaspora Global Network, defended the policy, arguing that denying education to undocumented children violates their fundamental rights.
“When children are in the country, they must be acknowledged and educated,” Sibanda said. “Denying them access is reckless and unlawful. Educating these children doesn’t grant them citizenship but ensures they have a chance at a better future.”
Sibanda also warned of the societal risks posed by excluding undocumented children from the education system, emphasizing that an uneducated population is more likely to engage in criminal activities.
Government’s Position and Response
Elijah Mahlangu, spokesperson for the Department of Basic Education, reiterated that the inclusion of undocumented children is not a new issue. He confirmed that the department is collaborating with Home Affairs, the Centre for Child Law, and the South African Human Rights Commission to address concerns and ensure equitable funding for all learners.
“The judgment found Clauses 15 and 21 of the School Admission Policy for Ordinary Public Schools unconstitutional,” Mahlangu stated. “There’s no discrimination in funding undocumented learners—they are treated like all other children.”
A Divided Nation
The debate over undocumented children in schools reflects broader concerns about immigration and resource allocation in South Africa. While critics like Mashaba call for stricter immigration controls and the repatriation of undocumented individuals, human rights advocates argue that denying education undermines the country’s values and commitments to child welfare.
The Way Forward
The controversy underscores the need for a balanced approach that addresses both legal obligations and resource constraints. Collaboration between the Department of Education, Home Affairs, and civil society organizations will be essential to developing sustainable solutions that protect the rights of all children while maintaining the integrity of South Africa’s education system.
As this debate continues to unfold, it raises critical questions about the nation’s priorities and its capacity to address complex social challenges. Will South Africa find a way to balance the needs of its citizens with its legal and ethical responsibilities to undocumented individuals? Only time will tell.
