When football fans in the country ask, which team has most trophies in South Africa, the conversation often sparks passionate debates. South African soccer has a rich history, and several clubs have enjoyed great success over the years. However, when measuring trophy haul, three teams stand out prominently: Kaizer Chiefs, Mamelodi Sundowns, and Orlando Pirates.

Contents

Each has a unique story and legacy that has shaped the football landscape in the country. This article explores which team has most trophies in South Africa, considering both historical success and recent achievements.

Kaizer Chiefs: The Most Decorated Club Overall

For decades, Kaizer Chiefs have been widely regarded as the most successful soccer team in the country in terms of sheer trophy count. Since their formation in 1970, the Chiefs have amassed a staggering 93 trophies across various competitions, making them the club with the most silverware in South African football history.

Their domestic success includes:

13 National Soccer League titles (before the PSL era)
13 Nedbank Cups (formerly known as the Telkom Knockout)
15 MTN8 titles
13 Telkom Knockouts
Multiple other regional and invitational trophies

Moreover, Kaizer Chiefs have a continental trophy to their name—the African Cup Winners’ Cup—secured in 2001, adding an international dimension to their honours list. Despite their dominance in the past, the club has experienced a relative drought in recent years, with their last major trophy win dating back to 2015. Nevertheless, the Chiefs remain the benchmark for success, often cited when answering the question of which team has most trophies in South Africa.

Mamelodi Sundowns: The Modern Era Giants

Mamelodi Sundowns have established themselves as the powerhouse of South African football in the modern era, particularly since the establishment of the Premier Soccer League (PSL) in 1996. While they do not yet surpass the Chiefs’ historical total, Sundowns are catching up fast, especially with their dominance in recent years.

The club boasts an impressive trophy cabinet with:

15 League titles (11 of which are PSL championships)
6 Nedbank Cup trophies
4 MTN8 trophies
4 Telkom Knockouts

On the continental stage, Sundowns have also stamped their authority. Their crowning achievement came in 2016 when they won the CAF Champions League—the continent’s most prestigious club competition. This was followed by a CAF Super Cup victory in 2017 and the recent African Football League title in 2023. These international triumphs place Sundowns among the elite football clubs in Africa.

Currently, Sundowns hold around 33 major trophies, and their consistent success in league and cup competitions fuels the ongoing discussion about which team has most trophies in South Africa, especially among younger fans who witnessed their recent run.

Orlando Pirates: The Proud Contenders

Another heavyweight in the trophy race is Orlando Pirates, affectionately known as the Buccaneers. The club is renowned for its passionate fanbase and historic achievements. With a total of 33 major trophies, Pirates sit comfortably among the top in the country.

Their domestic honours include:

9 League titles
10 Nedbank Cups
12 MTN8 trophies
1 Telkom Knockout

Internationally, Orlando Pirates made history in 1995 as the first South African club to win the CAF Champions League, a feat that elevated the club’s status beyond national borders. They followed this by winning the CAF Super Cup in 1996, securing their place as continental pioneers.

The Trophy Race: Who Tops the List?

Answering the question of which team has most trophies in South Africa requires considering different perspectives. Historically, Kaizer Chiefs lead with a record 93 trophies, dominating South African football for several decades. Their vast haul spans league titles, domestic cups, and continental success.

However, the Premier Soccer League era tells a slightly different story. Mamelodi Sundowns have been the most dominant team since 1996, claiming 15 league championships—the highest in the PSL era—and numerous cup trophies. Their continental successes add further weight to their case as arguably the most successful club in recent times.

Orlando Pirates, while behind Chiefs in total trophies, have a significant legacy, particularly due to their continental achievements in the 1990s. Their consistent performances in domestic competitions also make them a key player in South Africa’s football hierarchy.

Celebrating the Legacy of South African Football

When discussing which team has most trophies in South Africa, it’s important to celebrate the rich history and competitive spirit of these clubs. Kaizer Chiefs, Mamelodi Sundowns, and Orlando Pirates have all contributed immensely to the country’s football culture, inspiring generations of players and fans.

While Chiefs remain the record holders for total trophies, Sundowns’ recent dominance ensures the trophy race remains alive and exciting. Pirates continue to maintain their proud tradition with solid performances at home and abroad. Ultimately, these three clubs have set the standard for excellence and remain the true giants of South African soccer.