Adele’s Hit Song Under Fire
British pop sensation Adele, celebrated for her soulful voice and emotional ballads, finds herself at the center of a legal storm. A Brazilian court has ordered the removal of her song Million Years Ago from streaming platforms globally, following allegations that it bears striking similarities to a Brazilian samba classic.
The controversy emerged when Brazilian composer Toninho Geraes, 62, accused Adele of lifting elements from his 1995 track Mulheres (Women), a samba hit performed by Martinho da Vila. The case has ignited a debate on intellectual property and the global use of cultural music.
Also read: Sho Madjozi Announces Final Album: Why She’s Leaving the Music Industry
The Allegations: Undisguised Similarities
Geraes claims that from her 2015 album 25, Adele’s Million Years Ago shares more than a passing resemblance to his samba classic. After expert analysis, it was concluded that there is an “undisguised symmetry” between the melodies of the two tracks.
Judge Victor Torres, presiding over Rio de Janeiro’s sixth commercial court, issued an injunction last Friday, requiring Adele’s song to be removed from streaming platforms. The ruling includes a potential fine of $8,000 against the Brazilian branches of Sony and Universal—Adele’s labels—if they fail to comply.
Legal Repercussions for Adele’s Labels
In addition to the injunction, Geraes is seeking significant compensation, including lost royalties, $160,000 in moral damages, and songwriting credits on Adele’s track. His lawyer, Fredimio Trotta, has called the ruling a “game-changer” for Brazilian music, arguing that it will deter future misuse of local compositions by international artists.
Trotta’s legal team is actively working to notify global streaming platforms, radio stations, and broadcasters about the court’s decision. If fully enforced, Million Years Ago, which has been streamed over 223 million times on Spotify alone, could disappear from all digital platforms.
A Landmark Case for Brazilian Music
This lawsuit is more than just a dispute between artists—it’s a pivotal moment for Brazilian music. Trotta believes the ruling sets a precedent that will protect local artists from exploitation. He stated, “International producers and artists who have Brazilian music on their radar for possible parasitic use will think twice, given this decision.”
Geraes’ argument highlights a broader issue: the appropriation of cultural music without proper acknowledgment or compensation. His lawyer emphasized the importance of this case in ensuring that Brazilian music is no longer treated as a resource for uncredited inspiration.
Adele’s Silence and Industry Response
Neither Adele nor her representatives have commented publicly on the allegations. Sony Music Entertainment Brazil told AFP that they “do not have a statement at this time,” while Universal Music Brazil has yet to respond.
The music industry is no stranger to legal battles over copyright infringement. Cases like this highlight the fine line between inspiration and imitation, and the growing need for mechanisms to ensure fair compensation for original creators.
The Songs in Question
For those curious to compare the tracks, Million Years Ago and Mulheres have been made available online. The side-by-side comparisons have fueled public debate, with some listeners acknowledging the similarities while others argue the resemblance is coincidental.
What’s Next?
The case remains ongoing, with the court’s ruling likely to have ripple effects across the global music industry. If upheld, the decision could lead to stricter regulations and scrutiny regarding the use of cultural music in international compositions.
For Adele, the lawsuit adds a layer of complexity to her already illustrious career. Regardless of the outcome, this case underscores the importance of respecting artistic integrity and the contributions of musicians worldwide.
As the legal battle unfolds, it serves as a wake-up call for the music industry to address long-standing issues of copyright and fair compensation. Adele’s Million Years Ago may have been a global hit, but its fate now hinges on the courts’ final decision. For Toninho Geraes and many Brazilian artists, this case is a step toward reclaiming the respect and recognition they deserve.
