Volkswagen enthusiasts across South Africa have spoken, and the results are clear: the Golf GTI Mk5 has emerged as the nation’s favourite GTI generation, securing a remarkable 31.85% of the votes. Hot on its heels is the Mk7, with 31.40%, reflecting the lasting appeal of these iconic hatchbacks.

Contents

The Poll Results

POLL: Which Generation of Golf GTI Is the Best?

Volkswagen Golf GTI Mk5 – 31.85%
Volkswagen Golf GTI Mk7 – 31.40%
Volkswagen Golf GTI Mk6 – 13.48%
Volkswagen Golf GTI Mk2 – 7.35%
Volkswagen Golf GTI Mk8 – 5.16%
Volkswagen Golf GTI Mk1 – 4.84%
Volkswagen Golf GTI Mk4 – 2.97%
Volkswagen Golf GTI Mk3 – 2.97%

The Mk5, produced between 2004 and 2009, was a standout in the GTI’s evolution. Equipped with a 2.0-litre turbocharged engine delivering 147 kW, it was the first GTI to feature the now-legendary EA888 engine. The Mk5 brought a harmonious blend of performance, refinement, and timeless design, re-establishing the GTI as a driver’s favourite.

Why the Mk5 Stands Out

The Mk5’s enduring popularity can be attributed to two key factors: its timeless design and exceptional aftermarket support. Enthusiasts love its clean, understated styling that has aged gracefully over the years. Additionally, the Mk5 offers a robust aftermarket ecosystem, enabling owners to personalize and enhance their vehicles with performance upgrades and cosmetic modifications.

These attributes have made the Mk5 a classic choice for collectors and enthusiasts alike. Its blend of nostalgic charm and modern performance remains unmatched, as reflected in its dominance in the poll.

The Mk7: A Worthy Contender

Just a few years after the Mk5’s success, Volkswagen introduced the Mk7 in 2012. Built on the MQB platform, it improved on its predecessors with enhanced dynamics and reduced weight. Power outputs ranged from 162 kW to 180 kW across various trims, including the Performance Pack, Clubsport, and Clubsport S editions.

image 200 edited — Image: Volkswagen South Africa

In South Africa, the Mk7 gained additional momentum thanks to special editions like the Clubsport and TCR, which added exclusivity and further enhanced its performance credentials. The Mk7’s near-equal share of votes demonstrates its enduring appeal and recognition as one of the best all-around GTIs ever produced.

Key Features of Golf GTI Generations

Generation	Years Produced	Engine	Power Output	Notable Features
Mk1	1976–1983	1.6L/1.8L NA	81 kW–82 kW	Lightweight design, first hot hatch, iconic styling
Mk2	1984–1992	1.8L/2.0L NA	82 kW–102 kW	Improved build quality, bigger size, introduction of DOHC engines
Mk3	1993–1998	2.0L NA / 2.8L VR6	85 kW–128 kW	VR6 engine option, increased focus on comfort
Mk4	1999–2004	1.8L Turbo / 3.2L VR6	110 kW–177 kW	Introduction of turbocharging, more luxurious interior
Mk5	2004–2009	2.0L Turbocharged	147 kW	EA888 engine debut, independent rear suspension, timeless design, strong aftermarket support
Mk6	2010–2012	2.0L Turbocharged	155 kW	Improved interior quality, advanced safety features
Mk7	2012–2019	2.0L Turbocharged	162 kW–180 kW	MQB platform, Performance Pack, Clubsport editions, reduced weight
Mk8	2020–Present	2.0L Turbocharged	180 kW–235 kW	Digital cockpit, advanced driver-assist features, sharp exterior design

The Legacy Lives On

This poll not only highlights South Africa’s love for the GTI but also underscores the enduring legacy of Volkswagen’s hot hatch. Each generation has brought something unique, from the pioneering Mk1 to the tech-laden Mk8. While the Mk5 and Mk7 reign supreme in the hearts of enthusiasts, every GTI generation holds its own charm, contributing to the car’s rich heritage. Stay tuned for more polls and debates, and let your voice shape the conversation as we celebrate the beloved Golf GTI!