As the Springboks prepare for their biggest clash of the season against the All Blacks at Eden Park on 6 September, the flyhalf debate has begun to heat up. One name at the centre of this conversation is Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu.
Earlier this season, there were real concerns about his ability to stay fit. The talented 23-year-old couldn’t seem to string together a run of matches without breaking down. A collarbone injury in December against the Sharks added to a list that included a concussion and hip issue from the two previous games. Even before that, a knee injury against the All Blacks had ruled him out of the Boks’ end-of-year tour.
Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu: A Stormers Star on the Rise
Despite these setbacks, Feinberg-Mngomezulu bounced back impressively. After being crowned SA Rugby’s Young Player of the Year, he spoke about the silver lining his time off the field had brought him. “The injury layoff served me well,” he admitted. “I don’t take any opportunity for granted.”
Since returning in March, he’s reminded South African fans just how electric he can be. His performance against Connacht – where he scored a blistering 25-minute hat-trick – showed his full range of abilities: from clever chips and sharp passes to raw pace and attacking flair.
Eden Park: The Ultimate Test
Facing New Zealand in Auckland is no ordinary challenge. The All Blacks have not lost at Eden Park in over three decades, with 48 wins and two draws since 1994. If there’s one place to measure a player’s readiness for the global stage, it’s there.
This makes the upcoming Test a pivotal one for coach Rassie Erasmus. While he will use the upcoming fixtures against Italy, Georgia, and Australia to test combinations, the showdown at Eden Park is where the best must play.
Handré Pollard’s Proven Pedigree
Handré Pollard remains a household name in South African rugby. Currently completing his stint with Leicester Tigers, he’ll return to the Bulls on 1 July. Pollard’s leadership, game management, and goal-kicking under pressure are beyond question.
He’s been there and done it – guiding the Boks through World Cup finals and high-pressure Test series. However, to start against the All Blacks, form will be key, and he must prove he’s ready after his European season.
Comparing the Two Flyhalves
| Attribute | Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu | Handré Pollard |
|---|---|---|
| Age | 23 | 30 |
| Current Club | Stormers | Leicester Tigers (joining Bulls) |
| Test Experience | Limited but growing | 68+ Test caps |
| Kicking Accuracy | Solid, still developing | World-class |
| Attacking Flair | High – chips, breaks, offloads | Controlled, structured |
| Defensive Stability | Improving, aggressive | Consistent and reliable |
| Injury History (2024) | Several setbacks, now fit | Minor issues, largely fit |
| Fit for Eden Park? | Rising star, bold choice | Safe and experienced choice |
Form vs. Experience: Who Gets the Nod?
If this decision was purely about Test match pedigree, Pollard would get the nod without question. But Feinberg-Mngomezulu’s current form, combined with his versatility and alignment with Tony Brown’s attacking vision, makes him a compelling option.
He’s already impressed against top-tier opposition and playing in Auckland would be a defining test of his capabilities. It would also offer Erasmus valuable insights heading towards the 2027 World Cup.
Also read: Springboks’ 2025 Home Fixtures Confirmed – Here’s Where You Can Watch Them Live
Pollard’s legacy is secure, but if the Boks want to build for the future and shake off predictability in their attack, giving Feinberg-Mngomezulu the starting berth against the All Blacks might be a masterstroke. The time could be right for the young playmaker to show the rugby world what he’s made of – at the most daunting venue of them all.
